Vickys Coconut Milk 'Cheddar' Cheese, GF DF EF SF NF

Vickys Coconut Milk 'Cheddar' Cheese, GF DF EF SF NF

If you can't use my cashew cream cheese, hopefully you can use this one instead. It's great for sauces, sandwiches and crackers. It sets at room temp but depending on how much vinegar / agar you add you can change the level of set for a slicing consistency or a spreadable cheese

Vicky@Jacks Free-From Cookbook


30 servings
  1. 2 can full fat coconut milk, total amount 800mls
  2. 3 tbsp agar flakes or 3 tsp agar powder or as required
  3. 1/2 tsp cider vinegar or white balsamic
  4. 4 tbsp tapioca starch or corn starch/cornflour
  5. 1 tsp smoked paprika
  6. 2 tsp sea salt
  7. 15 grams (1/4 cup) nutritional yeast flakes


30 mins
  1. Blank step
    Add Photo

    Boil the coconut milk until it's no longer separated. Add the vinegar, agar flakes and salt. Boil gently for 15 minutes (no need to boil 15 minutes if using agar agar powder)

  2. Change

    Add the remaining ingredients one at a time, whisking continuously. Cook for another 5 - 10 minutes

  3. Change

    Take off the heat and scrape into a greased glass bowl or parchment paper lined small loaf tin

  4. Change

    Let cool two hours, it will set at room temperature. If you put in the fridge overnight you can slice and grate it. It's a little slippery though for grating and easier to just slice. If you can't wait to try it spread it on a cracker now lol

  5. Change

    Use sliced in sandwiches, top pizzas, melt for mac & cheese or use as a quesadilla filler!

  6. Blank step
    Add Photo

    Will make a block the same size as a 300g block of normal cheese but doesn't weigh that much!

  7. Blank step
    Add Photo

    The vinegar stops the agar setting so solid that you can't slice it. If you find it sets too hard, increase the vinegar by a half tsp. Likewise if it's too gellatinous, reduce the vinegar to a quarter tsp. I've only tried these 2 kinds of vinegar so I don't know if other varieties make a difference to set or flavour. Different brands of agar also state different setting amounrs on the packets. I use Clearspring brand

Add Step


Cooksnap placeholder

Have you cooked this recipe?

Share your version with a Cooksnap photo

Share your Cooksnap